HVAC energy questions · Checking the claims

How can I check whether an HVAC retrofit's savings and payback are credible, and how are they verified?

Credible savings are measured, not estimated: a metered baseline before the work, the same measurements afterwards, and adjustments for weather, occupancy and operating hours, following a recognised method such as IPMVP. Check payback by recomputing it yourself from the baseline kWh, the measured saving, your actual tariff and the full project cost.

What makes a baseline trustworthy?

It covers the same equipment, the same measurement boundary and representative operating conditions, measured with calibrated instruments before any work starts.

  • Measurement boundary defined: one unit, one chiller, the whole plant or the whole building
  • Period long enough to capture normal variation — at least one to four weeks of one-minute data for a chiller plant; twelve months of bills for a whole building
  • Instruments calibrated; for water-cooled plants, a heat balance within ±5% shows the measurements agree
  • Conditions recorded alongside energy: outdoor temperature and humidity, occupancy, operating hours, set-points

What is IPMVP, and which option fits my project?

The International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP), published by the Efficiency Valuation Organization, is the most widely used framework for proving energy savings. It offers four options.

OptionWhat is measuredSuits
A — Retrofit isolation, key parameterOne key parameter measured (e.g. power), others estimatedSimple measures with stable operation, such as lighting
B — Retrofit isolation, all parametersAll energy of the treated equipment metered before and afterCoil coating on specific units, refrigerant treatment, Aquene on a chiller loop
C — Whole facilityUtility meter for the whole building, adjusted by regressionSeveral measures together; savings larger than about 10% of the bill
D — Calibrated simulationEnergy model calibrated to measured dataNo baseline exists, or new construction

Savings = baseline energy adjusted to post-retrofit conditions − measured post-retrofit energy. Example: in the Dubai supermarket case, daily kWh was regressed against temperature over the baseline, and the model projected what seven units would have used without coating; actual use was 18.5% lower.

Which adjustments matter most in Singapore?

Weather, occupancy and operating hours — and any 'non-routine' change such as a new tenant or server room, which must be adjusted for separately.

  • Weather: cooling energy depends on outdoor temperature and humidity; compare at the same conditions or normalise by regression
  • Load: cooling delivered (RT-hours) — compare kW/RT, not just kWh, when load changes
  • Hours: extended trading or shift patterns
  • Non-routine changes: new equipment, vacancy, renovations — document them during the measurement period

How do I test a payback claim?

Recompute it: payback = total project cost ÷ (baseline kWh × measured saving % × your tariff). Check each input.

  • Is the baseline kWh realistic for the equipment's size and hours? Divide it by the hours to get average kW, and compare with the nameplate input power
  • Is the saving % measured on similar equipment, or assumed?
  • Is the tariff your actual contract rate, not a peak figure?
  • Are all costs included — access, shutdowns, M&V, maintenance?
  • Do overlapping measures double-count the same savings?
  • Will the savings persist, and how will that be checked after year one?

RCT publishes its Singapore payback calculations with every assumption stated, and measures each project before and after.

Official sources: Efficiency Valuation Organization — IPMVP; BCA Code on Periodic Energy Audit (heat balance, logging). Rules and schemes change; check the current version before acting.

Ask RCT to review your plant data All HVAC energy questions

Frequently asked questions

Who should do the measurement and verification?

Ideally an independent party, or the supplier under a method agreed with you in advance, using meters you can inspect. For statutory audits in Singapore, a PE(Mechanical) or BCA-registered Energy Auditor is required.

How long after the retrofit should I measure?

Allow any settling period the supplier specifies — for refrigerant treatments, a few weeks — then measure for a period comparable to the baseline.

Find out how much energy your building is losing

Tell us about your chiller plant, AHUs, refrigeration or fleet. We will suggest what to measure first, and whether a grant could fund the work.

WhatsApp us